Recorded grade range: $3.85–$1,200 · Updated Aug 12, 2026
Raw
$3.85
PSA 9
$115
PSA 10
$1,200
This is a market estimate, not a guaranteed sale price. The value of your copy depends on its exact print, condition and recent buyer demand. Last observed in the app: Aug 12, 2026. How market estimates work.
Check your exact cardScan it to identify the print and review condition.
No hidden values
John Bagley prices by grade
Last observed Aug 12, 2026
Grade
Estimated value
Raw
$3.85
PSA 10
$1,200
PSA 9
$115
PSA 8.5
$65.00
PSA 8
$49.99
PSA 7.5
$38.95
Show all 32 grades
Grade
Estimated value
PSA 7
$49.00
PSA 6
$15.50
PSA 5
$10.50
PSA 4
$10.00
SGC 10
$133
BGS 9.5
$275
SGC 9.5
$61.00
BGS 9
$19.50
CGC 9
$29.69
SGC 9
$39.99
BGS 8.5
$26.00
CGC 8.5
$18.08
SGC 8.5
$14.50
BGS 8
$60.00
CGC 8
$20.00
SGC 8
$50.00
BGS 7.5
$8.39
CGC 7.5
$16.29
SGC 7.5
$11.99
BGS 7
$36.99
SGC 7
$15.00
SGC 6.5
$5.50
BGS 6
$6.03
SGC 6
$19.62
BGS AUTH
$39.90
PSA AUTH
$59.09
Recorded market snapshots
Price history by grade
96 recorded points
Latest$3.85
30D change-61.5%
Recorded range$2.33–$10.50
Jul 13, 2026Aug 12, 2026
Latest$3.85
90D change-17.9%
Recorded range$2.33–$18.99
May 14, 2026Aug 12, 2026
Latest$3.85
1Y change+2.7%
Recorded range$2.33–$52.12
Aug 14, 2025Aug 12, 2026
Latest$1,200
30D change+65.6%
Recorded range$636–$1,200
Jun 22, 2026Jul 3, 2026
Latest$1,200
90D change-1.1%
Recorded range$636–$1,213
Apr 22, 2026Jul 3, 2026
Latest$1,200
1Y change+187.1%
Recorded range$418–$1,213
Sep 1, 2025Jul 3, 2026
Latest$115
30D change+42.0%
Recorded range$64.00–$161
Jul 20, 2026Aug 12, 2026
Latest$115
90D change-0.4%
Recorded range$64.00–$161
May 14, 2026Aug 12, 2026
Latest$115
1Y change+85.2%
Recorded range$46.00–$161
Aug 22, 2025Aug 12, 2026
View Raw history as a table
Date
Recorded estimate
Aug 12, 2026
$3.85
Aug 11, 2026
$6.99
Aug 10, 2026
$2.33
Aug 8, 2026
$5.47
Aug 6, 2026
$2.90
Aug 5, 2026
$8.50
Aug 4, 2026
$10.50
Aug 3, 2026
$4.86
Aug 2, 2026
$5.00
Jul 28, 2026
$5.99
Jul 27, 2026
$5.03
Jul 26, 2026
$5.65
Jul 25, 2026
$5.08
Jul 22, 2026
$5.99
Jul 15, 2026
$2.99
Jul 13, 2026
$9.99
View PSA 10 history as a table
Date
Recorded estimate
Jul 3, 2026
$1,200
Jun 23, 2026
$636
Jun 22, 2026
$725
Apr 22, 2026
$1,213
Feb 6, 2026
$1,165
Sep 29, 2025
$588
Sep 20, 2025
$900
Sep 1, 2025
$418
View PSA 9 history as a table
Date
Recorded estimate
Aug 12, 2026
$115
Aug 11, 2026
$96.54
Aug 10, 2026
$110
Aug 3, 2026
$125
Jul 29, 2026
$161
Jul 28, 2026
$99.99
Jul 25, 2026
$99.99
Jul 21, 2026
$64.00
Jul 20, 2026
$81.00
Jun 29, 2026
$74.40
Jun 6, 2026
$109
May 23, 2026
$100
May 18, 2026
$110
May 14, 2026
$116
Apr 28, 2026
$67.74
Apr 13, 2026
$110
How to read this value
What affects this card’s price?
The estimate above applies to the 1986 Fleer Basketball #5 printing. A card with the same character or player from another set can have a very different value.
Condition and professional grade
Centering, corners, edges and surface quality can move a card between raw and graded price levels. A high grade should never be assumed from a listing photo alone.
Variant and exact print
Parallel, holo, reverse holo, first-edition and promotional versions may use different price records. Confirm the set and card number first.
Market activity
The source snapshot recorded 47 sales over 30 days. Compare recent listings and completed sales before buying or selling.